Leg press, set three, quads screaming, earbuds jammed in at 2.0x, and I'm whisper-begging Koschei the Deathless to PLEASE get off his lake and start something. Because the drama? Not here yet. A 3.5-star reviewer called this one "very slow to start," and I'm not even arguing. That's just the receipt.
Normally a slow opener gets the chapter-three DNF and a stitch video explaining why. But this is ACOTAR. Book six. I have history with these people. So I stayed on the machine and stayed loyal.
And it mostly paid off. Mostly.
Koschei is stirring and the Night Court is too busy not speaking to each other
The setup is genuinely big: a deathless guy bound to a mountain lake for millennia, waking up, collecting allies who want the human lands back. Villain energy through the ROOF.
But the book keeps cutting away from him to the Night Court licking its wounds. Betrayals, truths that came out post-Hybern War, rifts that read as insurmountable. The title tells you the assignment. Repair first, fight second.
Narratively? Fair. You can't take on Koschei with a team that won't sit at the same table. As a listener? I checked my progress bar on the rowing machine. Twice. (Not proud. Moving on.)
If you've lived through five books of this found family, watching them try to un-break is the whole emotional meal. If you skimmed book one on a plane once, the opening is gonna feel like a group chat you weren't added to.
One voice, a whole court, and the head-hops that ate my 2.0x
Elizabeth Evans is why this works in audio. She handles the female and male leads effortlessly, and even if people clown her for mostly just dropping her pitch for Rhys and the batboys, that low register is rock-steady. It never drifts. So when the POVs start hopping, a Rhys line is the thing that snaps you back into place, like a landmark. Evans also narrates A Court of Mist and Fury (10th Anniversary Recording), and it's the same steady bass I kept hearing here.
The trouble is everybody who ISN'T in that bass range. When a new perspective kicks in, she doesn't do a dramatic reset, the tone just kind of continues, so at 2.0x I'd be three sentences deep before realizing I'd switched heads. More than once I hit a full "wait, whose head am I in?" stall. I dropped to 1.5x for the early chapters, let my brain learn the rotation, then cranked back up and it was fine. Real tax though. Budget for it.
This is exactly the problem a full cast solves, btw. In A Court of Mist and Fury (Part 1 of 2) (Dramatized Adaptation), every character has their own actor, so a POV switch is literally a different human voice in your ear. No guessing. One-narrator Evans gives you a more intimate vibe, but you trade some instant clarity for it.
Spice check, since y'all will ask: the focus here is Koschei, court politics, and stitching broken alliances back together, so expect this to sit lower on the steam meter than A Court of Silver Flames, which was built around Nesta and Cassian. That Nesta and Cassian heat gets the full-cast treatment in A Court of Silver Flames (Part 2 of 2) (Dramatized Adaptation), so that's where I'd point the spice seekers. Here the yearning is about the group, not the bedroom. If you're queuing purely for spice, recalibrate.
Coming in from Fourth Wing? Read this first
If Fourth Wing is your romantasy gateway, you're used to stakes from page one: cliffs, dragons, someone dying by lunch. This is the opposite energy. It's a slow emotional rebuild that only works if you already care about these specific people. Start at book one, not here. And if you only know Rhys from the Crescent City crossover in House of Sky and Breath, same advice: this book assumes you know every scar.
Spend the credit if you're five books deep, skip it if you need carnage early
Loyal Night Court girlies: yes. Evans makes the court feel like home, and watching them repair after watching them fall apart hits.
But if you need action in the first couple hours, even knowing the payoff comes later, this will test you. And that ending? Abrupt doesn't even cover it. It just... stops. A Court of Forgotten Melody is right there on the series list, and this book absolutely knows it.
Re-racking the plates, still mad at that last chapter
I walked out with dead legs and Koschei STILL sitting at the bottom of his lake, the court only half-stitched, and Evans's Rhys voice stuck on loop in my head. First act drags, POV juggling costs you clarity, the cliffhanger is rude. I'm still spending the credit, and I'm already side-eyeing the release date for book seven.
















