What happens to wanting when your whole life has been reorganized around someone else's decline? I ask some version of that question every week, usually to a fifteen-year-old who's translating at a parent's medical appointments and hasn't thought about their own future since eighth grade. So I didn't expect a romance with a kitten-cuddling veterinarian on the cover to ask it back.
I started this in the waiting room at Luna's annual checkup, of all places. Disinfectant smell, a guy across from me with a carrier full of mewling foster kittens, Luna pressed against my shins pretending she wasn't scared. Then Christine Lakin introduces Xavier Rush as basically a Greek statue with a stethoscope, and I laughed out loud loud enough that the kitten guy looked up. Then Xavier opens his mouth, says something truly wrong, and Samantha goes after him for it. Good. I liked her immediately.
Begging him to forget her is a coping strategy, and I clocked it
The hook of the book is Samantha asking Xavier, after one perfect night, to just remember it and let her go. Her family is in crisis, with a parent who has dementia, and she's decided there's no room for a relationship.
And as a counselor? I recognized that move instantly. It's not noble. It's not exactly unhealthy either - it's the thing people do when they've decided their needs are a luxury the household can't afford. Pre-grieving the good thing so it can't be taken from you later. I've watched kids do it with friendships, with college applications, with coming out (I did it myself, for years, telling myself my family had enough going on).
What Jimenez gets right is that she doesn't treat this as a silly obstacle for the hero to bulldoze. The caregiving weight feels lived-in. It's tired, repetitive, and guilt-soaked, and it doesn't get fixed by a good man showing up. The question is whether Samantha can let someone in without abandoning her people. That's the real love story. Jimenez does a version of this in Friend Zone too, where real weight sits underneath all the banter and nobody pretends the banter fixes it.
No, this isn't a queer book, and it doesn't pretend to be. But it understands something I care about a lot: family is defined by who keeps showing up when it gets ugly. That instinct is here. I didn't feel like anyone was sanding the edges off for comfort.
Clipped sentences and a very long night locked in a room
This is duet narration done the satisfying way. Each narrator voices their own character's dialogue even in the other's chapters, so Xavier always sounds like Matt Lanter and Samantha always sounds like Lakin. No jarring swap where the hero suddenly gets a higher register halfway through a scene.
Lanter plays Xavier in short, clipped lines that read as guarded rather than cold. You can hear a man rationing himself. Lakin carries the heavier load emotionally. Her scenes around Samantha's family have this unforced warmth, like she's not performing sadness, she's just tired with Samantha. It's the same reason I trust her with a long emotional stretch, and I felt it in Royal We too. Side characters get distinct voices too. Xavier's coworkers and Samantha's brother add some real comic relief, which this book needs.
The first date, the two of them locked overnight in an escape room, is where the duet format pays off. The banter timing is sharp. You get two people auditioning for each other in real time, both narrators clearly enjoying it.
The flaw, and it's real: the laughs and little vocal noises. Sometimes a chuckle lands perfectly in a flirty exchange. Other times it bleeds into a moment that should hurt, and it pulled me out right when I was getting misty. Not a dealbreaker. But noticeable enough that I'd knock a point off a performance that's otherwise close to excellent.
The year that felt longer than a year
Here's where I get honest. The middle stretch, the long-distance part, drags in places. The emotional beats start repeating: longing, obstacle, reassurance, longing again. I listened at 1.25x (I always do, but here it actually mattered), and the slower chapters still felt padded. Some listeners say the second half felt repetitive, and I get it.
But, and this is my counselor brain talking, the repetition is also kind of the point? Caregiving IS repetitive. Distance IS repetitive. I just wish a couple of those loops had been trimmed so the payoff hit harder.
I teared up anyway. Not at one big scene, but at the small sweet ones, which sneak up on you more.
If you're the one holding everyone together right now
You'll probably feel seen, and maybe a little called out. That's worth a credit. If you want something light to escape into, know that the dementia storyline is not background decoration. It sits in the room the whole time. And if you need tight pacing, the middle will test your patience.
What I'd write in the session notes
Client presents as funny, brave, and convinced she doesn't get to want things. Progress: slow, nonlinear, real. Luna got a clean bill of health, by the way. I sat in the car afterward finishing a chapter before I'd let myself drive home.
















