Look, I started this book while designing wedding invitations for a client, which felt cosmically appropriate. By chapter three, I had mascara running down my face and had to pause because I couldn't see my screen. By the end? I'd gone through half a box of tissues and texted my best friend just to tell her I love her.
This book wrecked me in the best possible way.
The Emotional Sucker Punch I Didn't See Coming
Here's the thing about Abby Jimenez - she lures you in with banter and sarcasm and a dog named Stuntman Mike (I mean, COME ON), and then she just... destroys you. Kristen is facing a hysterectomy. She can't have kids. And Josh, this beautiful disaster of a man who wants a big family, keeps showing up with chicken enchiladas and being impossibly perfect.
The infertility storyline hit different for me. I wish Anna Karenina had explored its female characters' grief with this kind of raw honesty instead of just judgment. My cousin went through something similar last year, and hearing Kristen's internal monologue - the way she's already decided she's not enough, that she should step aside so Josh can have the life he deserves - ugh. My heart. MY HEART. Jimenez doesn't sugarcoat it or wrap it in a neat bow. The grief is messy and real and sometimes Kristen makes choices that made me want to shake her through my headphones.
But that's what makes it work, you know? She's not a perfect heroine. She's scared and stubborn and pushes people away because she thinks she's protecting them. Abuela would have been yelling at her in Spanish.
Let's Talk About Teddy Hamilton and Erin Mallon
Okay, so Teddy Hamilton? Chef's kiss. His Josh is warm and funny and you can HEAR the smile in his voice when he's teasing Kristen. The man knows how to deliver a line. When things get heavy, he doesn't oversell it - he just lets the emotion sit there, and it's devastating.
Erin Mallon is... more complicated. I've seen some listeners absolutely love her and others find her style distracting. I'm somewhere in the middle? There's this thing she does at the end of sentences, this slight over-emphasis, that took me a few chapters to adjust to. Once I did, I was fine. But I can see how it might pull some people out of the story.
The chemistry between them though - undeniable. When Josh and Kristen are bantering, you can feel the spark. These two have clearly worked together before (or should, constantly), because their timing is impeccable. The romantic tension builds through their vocal interplay in a way that just wouldn't land the same on the page.
Save This One for a Rainy Sunday
I listened over three days while working, and honestly? I should have saved it for a weekend where I could just curl up with my cats and let myself feel everything. The pacing is quick - nine and a half hours flew by - but the emotional beats need room to breathe.
The vibes are immaculate in that specific way where you're laughing one minute and crying the next. Jimenez balances the heavy stuff (and there's a LOT of heavy stuff - car accidents, loss, toxic parents) with genuine humor that never feels forced. Kristen's sarcasm is a defense mechanism, and you can hear that in Mallon's delivery even when the jokes are landing.
Content warnings are real here. Mental illness, OCD, a character in a coma, death, infertility. If any of those are sensitive topics for you, maybe have some self-care ready. I was not prepared for how hard some of those scenes hit.
Who Needs This in Their Ears (And Who Should Skip)
If you want a romance that makes you ugly-cry AND laugh out loud, this is your book. Perfect for anyone who's tired of heroines without real problems. Skip it if you need lighter fare or if the content warnings above hit too close to home right now - no shame in that.
Abuela's Final Word
Absolutely going in my comfort re-listen rotation. Maybe not immediately - I need to emotionally recover first - but this is the kind of book that reminds you why you read romance in the first place. Not for the escapism (though that's nice), but for the reminder that love is messy and complicated and worth fighting for anyway.
The production is clean, the pacing works, and despite my minor quibbles with Mallon's delivery, the overall experience is exactly what I want from a contemporary romance audiobook. Funny, heartfelt, and emotionally devastating in the best way.
Abuela would have ugly-cried right alongside me. And then made me watch a telenovela to recover.
















