🎧
AudiobookSoul
Lives of the Queens of England Volume 1 audiobook cover

Lives of the Queens of England Volume 1 — Fascinating royal history ruined by robotic narration

Skip, 2.0 Editorial, 1.0 Narration

Triage Notes

Quick Take

  • •Bedside Manner: Monotone, robotic, and full of painful mispronunciations.
  • •Clinical Accuracy: Good historical facts if you can get past the delivery.

Is this for you?

Pick this if:

  • you want medieval queen history and can tolerate robotic monotone narration
  • you love royal political drama and don't mind dense 19th-century prose
  • you seek English queens' stories and will push through painful mispronunciations

Skip if:

  • you need engaging narration or mostly listen while driving distracted
  • you prefer modern scholarship over dated flowery historical writing
  • you want smooth delivery and can't stand constant name mispronunciations
📚Best for fans of: Game of Thrones, Spare
Read Time3 min read
Duration9h 51m
Best Speed1.25x recommended
Your rating?
Maria Santos, audiobook curator
Reviewed byMaria Santos

Healthcare worker, 15 years hospital experience. Yells at dashboard when medical thrillers get it wrong.

🎧 Listens best driving home from night shift, needs historically badass women done right, turned off by disaster narration.

Last updated:

Share:

Night Shift Mode

Perfect For

Look, I have a high tolerance for pain. I've been an ICU nurse for 15 years—I can handle screaming patients, angry surgeons, and the sound of a ventilator alarm at 3 AM. But this audiobook? This tested me.

I picked this up because I wanted to know more about the women who ran England while the men were off swinging swords. Queens like Matilda and Eleanora of Aquitaine? Total bosses. Exactly the kind of energy I need after a twelve-hour shift dealing with trauma cases. I was ready for some medieval drama to decompress on the drive home to Gilbert.

Instead, I spent forty-five minutes yelling at my car speakers.

When the Vital Signs Flatline

Let's rip the bandage off right now—the narration is a disaster.

I don't say that lightly. I know narrating is hard work. But Ann Boulais reads this text with the emotional range of a heart monitor that's been unplugged. Monotone. Robotic. No inflection where there should be, weird pauses where there shouldn't be.

It reminded me of when first-year residents try to present a patient history during rounds, and they're so nervous they just drone on without breathing. Except this is nine hours long.

And the pronunciations? Carlos asked me why I looked so stressed when I walked in the door, and I had to explain that someone butchering French names for an hour is worse than traffic on the I-10. It sounds like she's never seen these names before. One listener called it a "parody of a really bad newscaster," and honestly? They weren't wrong.

Good History, Buried Under Bad Delivery

Here's the tragedy: the actual book is interesting. Agnes and Elisabeth Strickland wrote this back in the 1800s, so yeah, the style is dated and flowery. It's not modern scholarship. But they did the work—dug up sources nobody else was using at the time.

The stories are there. Matilda of Flanders, Matilda of Scotland—these women had lives that make Game of Thrones look like a kindergarten play. They navigated wars, politics, and impossible marriages.

But the writing is dense. Old-fashioned. To make that work in audio, you need a narrator who can act. Someone who can take a 19th-century sentence and give it rhythm so the listener can actually follow the thread. This narration is so flat and choppy that the meaning just gets lost. I found myself rewinding constantly—not because I was distracted, but because the sentence structure fell apart in the delivery.

The Shift Change Report

I wanted to love this. I really did. My mom is always telling me I should read more "serious" history instead of just thrillers, and I thought this was my ticket. Honestly, I had better luck with Spare—at least Prince Harry's story kept me engaged on the commute.

But I can't recommend the audio. It's physically difficult to listen to. If you're a medieval history buff who can push through rough narration, maybe—but even then, you'll be fighting the delivery the whole way. Everyone else? Skip this recording entirely.

If you're interested in the Queens of England—and you should be, because their stories are wild—do yourself a favor and buy the physical book. Or find a modern biography.

This recording? It's a Code Blue. Save yourself the stress.

Chart Review

Audio & Content Notes

These audio issues are minor for most listeners. Worth weighing if you listen in noisy places or are sensitive to production quality.

Quick Info

Release Date:January 1, 2016
Duration:9h 51m
Language:English
Best Speed:1.25x
Audio Code:58694736

About the Narrator

Ann Boulais

Ann Boulais is an audiobook narrator known for her work on historical and spiritual texts. She has narrated works such as 'Lives of the Queens of England Volume 5,' 'Story of a Soul,' and 'The First Book of Adam and Eve.' Her narration is noted for its gentle, precise, and authentic delivery, bringing a sense of wisdom and intimacy to spiritual autobiographies.

11 books
2.9 rating

Enjoyed this review? Rate it!

📬

Get Our Audiobook Picks

A themed issue every two weeks: a few honest picks from our curators. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe on Substack

Ready to listen free?