🎧
AudiobookSoul
28 Summers audiobook cover

28 Summers β€” Heartbreaking romance spanning 28 Nantucket summers

Must Listen, 4.5 Editorial, 5.0 Narration

Mom's Notes

Quick Take

  • β€’Easy on Tired Ears?: Erin Bennett delivers distinct character voices and flawless pacing that makes every emotional gut punch land perfectly across decades.
  • β€’Overall Vibe: A deceptively simple summer beach read that turns messy, forbidden love into something deeply human and heartbreaking.
  • β€’Nap-Time Friendly?: Seamlessly weaves nearly 30 years of timelines and pop culture without ever losing the emotional thread, even through countless pauses.

Is this for you?

Pick this if:

  • you love messy human summer romances and will root for a long affair
  • you want emotional depth while multitasking without tracking complex casts
  • you enjoy nostalgia-soaked love stories and don't mind a known ending

Skip if:

  • you treat affairs as a hard no and need clear moral condemnation
  • you need constant plot surprises rather than a powerful known ending
  • you want short listens and won't commit to a fifteen-hour arc
πŸ“šBest for fans of: Golden Girl, Identicals
Read Time4 min read
Duration15h 26m
Best Speed1.25x recommended
Your rating?
Rachel Morrison, audiobook curator
Reviewed byRachel Morrison

Mom of 3. Audiobook time is 45min hiding in car. No shame.

🎧 Catches audiobooks car-in-the-garage time, loves impossible heartbreaking love stories, can't survive books requiring character wikis.

Last updated:

Share:

Okay, so here's the thing about 28 Summers - I started this book thinking I'd knock it out in a week, maybe two. Fifteen and a half hours later, I'm emotionally compromised and questioning every life choice I've ever made. And I mean that in the best possible way.

Look, I knew what I was getting into. Elin Hilderbrand is basically the queen of summer beach reads, and I've been a fan for years. But this one? This one hit different. Maybe because I listened to most of it during my sacred car-in-the-garage time, alone with my thoughts and Erin Bennett's voice telling me about Mallory and Jake's impossible, beautiful, heartbreaking love story.

The premise is deceptively simple - two people meet at a bachelor party on Nantucket in 1993 and spend one weekend together every summer for 28 years. That's it. That's the whole thing. Except it's not simple at all, because life keeps happening around them. Jake gets married to Ursula (who, spoiler alert, becomes a presidential candidate - yeah, it goes there). Mallory builds a life on Nantucket. They both have kids. And every Labor Day weekend, they find their way back to each other.

I should probably hate these characters. I mean, it's an affair. A long-running, decades-long affair. But Hilderbrand does something sneaky - she makes you root for them anyway. She makes you understand how two fundamentally good people can make this choice, year after year, and how it shapes everything around them. It's messy and complicated and so, so human.

Why Erin Bennett Was Born to Narrate This

Let's talk about Erin Bennett, because honestly? She's the reason this audiobook works as well as it does. I've listened to her narrate other Hilderbrand books and she just gets it. She brought that same magic to Golden Girl, another Hilderbrand story where she had to juggle multiple timelines and emotional gut punches. Every character has a distinct voice - you can tell who's speaking without the "he said, she said" tags. Her pacing is spot on, which matters a lot when you're jumping between decades and dealing with a story that spans nearly 30 years of pop culture references, political drama, and emotional gut punches.

The way she handles Mallory's voice - warm but with this undercurrent of longing - made me tear up more than once. (Fine, more than five times. I'm not proud.) And when we get to the final chapters? I had to pull over in the school pickup line because I couldn't see through the tears. Worth it though.

One tiny thing - apparently there's a mispronunciation of a character name that's an Arrested Development reference, and once someone pointed it out online I couldn't unhear it. But honestly, that's such a minor complaint for what is otherwise a basically flawless narration.

847 Pauses and I Never Lost the Thread

Here's what I loved most: this book survived approximately 847 pauses (Sophie decided nap time was optional that week) and I never once lost the thread. The structure - jumping back and forth between past summers and the present day - could have been confusing, but it wasn't. Every time I came back to it, I knew exactly where we were and what was happening. That's not nothing when you're listening in 15-minute chunks between snack requests and sibling disputes.

The nostalgia factor is real, too. Each summer chapter is packed with period-appropriate details - the music, the movies, the news events. It's like a time capsule wrapped in a love story. I found myself texting my college roommate about songs we used to listen to in the late '90s. She had no idea why. I couldn't explain without spoiling everything.

Is it predictable? In some ways, yes. You know from the beginning that Mallory is dying - that's literally how the book opens. But knowing the ending doesn't make the journey any less powerful. Sometimes you don't need to be surprised. Sometimes you just need to feel something. Identicals gave me that same kind of emotional punch, also narrated by Erin Bennett with the same ability to make you care about complicated people.

My one caveat: if you're someone who can't handle morally gray relationship situations, this might not be your book. The affair is central to everything, and while Hilderbrand doesn't exactly glorify it, she doesn't condemn it either. It's complicated. Like most things worth reading about.

At 15+ hours, this is definitely a commitment. But it never dragged for me. I actually slowed down toward the end because I didn't want it to be over. (I know, I know - who has time for that? But some books earn it.)

Who's Going to Love This (And Who Should Skip)

Perfect for multitasking moms who want something with emotional depth but won't require a spreadsheet to track the characters. Skip it if affairs are a hard no for you - no judgment, but this one won't change your mind. My book club would love this if I ever have time for book club again.

Car time approved. Nap time approved. Ugly-crying-in-the-Target-parking-lot approved.

Comfort Level

Audio & Content Notes

Quick Info

Release Date:June 16, 2020
Duration:15h 26m
Language:English
Best Speed:1.25x
Audio Code:58694736

About the Narrator

Erin Bennett

Erin Bennett is an award-winning Los Angeles-based narrator, actress, singer, and voice-over artist with a passion for storytelling. She has narrated over 600 titles across a wide range of genres and has been nominated for multiple Earphones and Audie awards. Erin is recognized as one of the most versatile narrators in the audiobook industry.

39 books
4.1 rating

Enjoyed this review? Rate it!

πŸ“¬

Get Our Audiobook Picks

A themed issue every two weeks: a few honest picks from our curators. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe on Substack

Ready to listen free?