šŸŽ§
AudiobookSoul
New York to Dallas audiobook cover

New York to Dallas — Eve Dallas faces her own monsters

Must Listen, 5.0 Editorial, 5.0 Narration

Triage Notes

Quick Take

  • •Bedside Manner: Susan Ericksen is a chameleon, perfectly balancing Irish accents, terrified whispers, and gritty detective noir.
  • •Emotional Depth: Moves beyond the standard police procedural into a deep, painful exploration of trauma and recovery.
  • •Patient Profile: Dark, psychological, and intense—perfect for a long night shift or a lonely drive.

Is this for you?

Pick this if:

  • you want a strong heroine facing demons instead of just punching villains
  • you love dark psychological intensity and can handle raw trauma recovery
  • you enjoy deep character-driven procedurals with unflinching emotional depth

Skip if:

  • you need a light listen or prefer to avoid childhood abuse themes
  • you want standard police procedurals without psychological breakdowns
  • you mostly listen while distracted and need easy background noise
šŸ“šBest for fans of: Abandoned in Death, Firekeeper's Daughter
Read Time3 min read
Duration13h 49m
Best Speed1.25x recommended
Your rating?
Maria Santos, audiobook curator
Reviewed byMaria Santos

Healthcare worker, 15 years hospital experience. Yells at dashboard when medical thrillers get it wrong.

šŸŽ§ Listens best driving home nights, needs emotionally devastating character moments, turned off by inaccurate medical details.

Last updated:

Share:

Night Shift Mode

Perfect For

"She had a badge. She had a gun. But inside, she was just a child again."

I heard this line somewhere on the I-10 at 3:45 AM, and I literally had to pull over into a gas station parking lot because I couldn't focus on the road. The streetlights were humming, my scrubs were stained with something I hoped was just iodine, and Susan Ericksen was absolutely wrecking me.

Usually, I need these drives to decompress. To leave the trauma of the ER at the hospital doors so I don't bring it home to Carlos and the kids. But *New York to Dallas*? It dragged the trauma right into the passenger seat.

The Voice Inside the Nightmare

Let's be real—Susan Ericksen is the only reason I've stuck with this series for 30+ books. She brings that same intensity to Abandoned in Death, though nothing quite matches the raw emotion she delivers here. (Yes, I know that's a lot of credits. Don't do the math, Carlos will have a heart attack.)

In this one, she earns every single penny. Because this isn't the usual "Eve Dallas catches a bad guy" routine. This is Eve breaking down. The villain, Isaac McQueen, is a monster from Eve's past—one of those predators that makes even seasoned ER nurses like me want to lock the doors. Ericksen does something terrifying here: she shifts Eve's voice. Usually, Eve is steel and grit. But in the flashback scenes? You hear the terrified kid. The vulnerability cracks through the armor.

And then she switches to Roarke—that rich, Irish velvet voice—and you can practically feel him trying to hold Eve together. (My husband is great, but he doesn't sound like a billionaire Irish rogue, sadly.) The way Ericksen juggles the panic of the victim and the steady, terrified love of the partner? It's the best work she's done in the series.

When the PTSD Hits Home

Okay, putting my nurse hat on. A lot of thrillers treat trauma like a plot device. Something to make the character "edgy."

J.D. Robb (and Ericksen) gets the physiology of fear right in this book. The adrenaline dump. The freezing up. The way the past bleeds into the present until you can't tell where you are. Eve goes back to Dallas to hunt this guy, and it's a descent into hell. Messy. Ugly.

There were moments—specifically when Eve visits the site of her childhood abuse—where I felt that familiar tightness in my chest that I get during a Code Blue. It's visceral. The writing doesn't shy away from the brutality of what happened to her, but it doesn't feel exploitative. It feels like a case study in survival. Firekeeper's Daughter handles trauma with that same careful balance—unflinching but never gratuitous.

Also, can we talk about Peabody? Thank God for Peabody. Ericksen voices her with this sturdy, reliable warmth that acts like a pressure valve. When the darkness got too heavy, Peabody's loyalty was the only thing keeping the story from being suffocating.

Who This Is (and Isn't) For

If you've got triggers regarding sexual abuse or childhood trauma, proceed with caution—seriously. This is not a "light listen" while you fold laundry. But if you want to see a strong female character actually deal with her demons instead of just punching them? This is it.

Clocking Out

I sat in my driveway for twenty minutes after I got home, just staring at the garage door, letting the ending settle before I went inside to make pancakes.

My mom always wanted me to be a doctor so I could "fix" people. This book reminded me that some things—like the past—can't be fixed with a scalpel. You just have to survive them.

Night shift approved. But maybe keep the lights on.

Chart Review

Audio & Content Notes

Quick Info

Release Date:September 13, 2011
Duration:13h 49m
Language:English
Best Speed:1.25x
Audio Code:58694736

About the Narrator

Susan Ericksen

Susan Ericksen is an Illinois-born actress and audiobook narrator who earned her bachelor's degree from Macalester College and her Master of Fine Arts in acting from Southern Methodist University. Based in Minnesota alongside her husband, fellow narrator David Colacci, she has performed at regional venues including The Cleveland Play House and Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park while recording more than 800 audiobooks. Ericksen is best known as the signature voice of Lieutenant Eve Dallas across Nora Roberts's In Death series (written as J.D. Robb). Her command of brisk pacing and dozens of distinct dialects has earned over 20 AudioFile Earphones Awards and multiple Audie Awards, including wins for Origin in Death, New York to Dallas, Thankless in Death, Dark in Death, and Meg Gardiner's The Nightmare Thief.

94 books
4.4 rating

Enjoyed this review? Rate it!

šŸ“¬

Get Our Audiobook Picks

A themed issue every two weeks: a few honest picks from our curators. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Subscribe on Substack

Ready to listen free?