Okay, so here's the thing. I started this audiobook while working on a rebrand for a local coffee shop, and by chapter three I had completely abandoned my color palette because I was too busy clutching my chest like Abuela watching her telenovelas. Eclipse got me. It really got me.
I know, I know. Twilight discourse in 2024. But listen - I'm not here to debate whether Edward is problematic or if Bella should've picked Jacob. (She shouldn't have, fight me.) I'm here to talk about how Ilyana Kadushin made me feel things I wasn't prepared to feel on a random Tuesday afternoon while Diego judged me from the windowsill.
That Voice Though
Kadushin's narration is like... okay, imagine your cool older cousin who actually listens when you talk about your relationship drama, and she's telling you this story late at night when everyone else is asleep. That's the vibe. Her Bella is introspective without being whiny - which, let's be real, is a tightrope walk with this character. She captures all that messy teenage longing and confusion, and there were moments where I literally stopped designing mid-stroke because the emotional delivery hit too hard.
The tribal legend section? MY HEART. Kadushin shifts into this storytelling rhythm that felt ancient and intimate at the same time. Like sitting around a fire while someone weaves history and myth together. I actually rewound that part twice. Not because I missed something - because I wanted to feel it again.
Let's Talk About Edward's Voice
Now. The elephant in the room. Her Edward voice. Some people find it creepy and I... kind of get it? There's something slightly off about hearing Edward's dialogue in a feminine register that's trying to sound masculine and mysterious. It took me a few chapters to adjust. But honestly? I grew into it. By the time we hit the tent scene (you know the one), I was fully locked in and didn't care anymore.
Matt Walters does the Jacob chapters, and here's where I have a tiny bone to pick. His narration is solid - warm, a little rough around the edges, very fitting for Jacob's POV. But there's so little of it! It's like ordering a dual-flavor ice cream and getting one scoop of chocolate and a tiny smear of vanilla. I wanted more balance. The switch between narrators could've added so much dimension to the love triangle tension, but instead it feels like Walters got the short end of the stake. (See what I did there? I'm hilarious.)
Sixteen Hours of Emotional Weather
The pacing works beautifully for a 16-hour listen. There are slower moments - the build-up chapters where Bella's just existing in her anxiety about graduation and Victoria and choosing between two boys who would literally die for her. But those quiet stretches let the tension simmer. And when things escalate? When the newborn army stuff kicks in? Time flew. I finished the last four hours in one sitting and had to apologize to my client for the late mockups.
This book felt like being wrapped in a weighted blanket during a thunderstorm. Cozy but with an undercurrent of something dangerous. The romance hits different in audio because you're hearing every loaded pause, every breath before a confession. That same intensity of first loveβwhere every moment feels life-or-deathβis what drew me to Release Me: The Stark Series #1, though that one trades vampires for billionaires. Kadushin understands emotional subtlety in a way that makes the melodrama feel earned rather than eye-roll-worthy.
I ugly-cried at chapter 26. And again somewhere near the end - I lost track because I was too busy being emotionally compromised. Abuela would have loved this one. She was a sucker for impossible love triangles and dramatic declarations. I can almost hear her gasping at the proposal scene.
Your Heart, Your Call
If you're a Twilight nostalgic who wants to revisit Forks with fresh ears, absolutely yes. If you love teen romance with supernatural stakes and you're not precious about pacing, you'll dig it. Young adult listeners, commuters who want something immersive - this is your rainy Sunday book stretched across a whole week. But if you're impatient with slow-burn emotional setup, this might test you. If dual narration with uneven distribution bothers you, be warned. And if you absolutely cannot handle a female narrator voicing male characters, maybe read instead.
The production is clean - no weird background noise, no jarring music drops. Just you and Bella's inner turmoil for sixteen hours.
Abuela Would Approve
Look, Eclipse isn't trying to be literary fiction. It's trying to make you feel the weight of impossible choices and first love that feels like the end of the world. And in audio? With Kadushin's velvet-and-honey delivery? It succeeds. The vibes are immaculate. I'm not sorry.
















