Okay, so I need to talk about the 34-hour commitment that is Deadhouse Gates. And yes, I said 34 hours. That's like... 17 round-trip commutes from SF to Mountain View. I know because I counted. Every. Single. One.
Look, here's the thing about Malazan - you don't just casually listen to it. You survive it. And this second book? It broke me on a Tuesday somewhere around hour 22, during the Chain of Dogs sequence, and I'm not even embarrassed to admit I was silently crying on a packed Caltrain while a guy next to me ate the world's smelliest breakfast burrito.
The Commitment That Actually Pays Off
Bottom Line: This is basically Game of Thrones but with even more characters and zero hand-holding. Before They Are Hanged has that same brutal complexity, though Abercrombie at least gives you a few more breadcrumbs. Erikson drops you into a world mid-apocalypse and expects you to keep up. The first few hours are rough - you're juggling multiple continents, a rebellion called the Whirlwind, undead warriors, shapeshifters, and enough proper nouns to make your brain short-circuit. I had to restart chapter 3 twice because I zoned out during a 6 AM train.
But then something clicks. Around hour 8 or 9, the threads start weaving together, and suddenly you're completely invested in Coltaine's desperate march across the desert with 30,000 refugees. The Chain of Dogs sequence is genuinely one of the most brutal, emotionally devastating military campaigns I've ever experienced in fantasy. It's war without glory, just survival and sacrifice and moments that hit like a gut punch.
The magic system here is bonkers complex - warrens, ascendants, elder gods - and Erikson doesn't pause to explain anything twice. This is not a casual listen. I'd rate it "requires coffee" for commute-worthiness. But if you can handle the density, the payoff is massive.
Ralph Lister: A Narrator You'll Have Opinions About
So here's where it gets complicated. Ralph Lister is... fine? Good, even? But also polarizing in a way I didn't expect. His delivery is clear and dramatic - he's definitely trying to differentiate between the massive cast, and for the most part, he succeeds. The pacing works for the epic scope. He handles the battle sequences with appropriate weight.
But I'll be honest - there were stretches where his delivery felt a bit flat. Not monotone exactly, but... steady? In a book with this much emotional range, sometimes I wanted more vocal variety. The quiet moments and the devastating moments occasionally landed at the same intensity level, which muted some of the impact.
That said, by the end of 34 hours, his voice became the voice of this world for me. Stockholm syndrome? Maybe. But I genuinely can't imagine continuing the series with a different narrator now. He grew on me like a weird fungus. (That's a compliment, I think?)
Who Should Sacrifice 34 Hours (And Who Should Run)
Perfect for: Long commuters who want something that demands attention. Gym sessions where you need distraction from leg day. Anyone who's ever complained that fantasy is too simple.
Skip if: You need instant gratification. You're not willing to re-listen to sections. You want a narrator who does wildly different character voices.
The ROI on this audiobook is high, but the upfront investment is brutal. Think of it like a distributed systems migration - painful during, worth it after. (Sorry, work brain never turns off.)
Sitting in the Caltrain Parking Lot, Unable to Pause
I finished this across probably 20+ commutes, and there were days I dreaded the density. But there were also days I sat in the parking lot for an extra ten minutes because I couldn't pause mid-battle. The Chain of Dogs ending? I had to take a walk around the office before I could focus on code. That level of emotional devastation is rare - I've only felt it a handful of times, and Before They Are Hanged was one of them.
This isn't a casual recommendation. It's a warning and a promise wrapped together. Deadhouse Gates will wreck you if you let it, but you have to earn that devastation through hours of worldbuilding first. For me, totally worth it. Your mileage may vary based on your tolerance for complexity and your commute length.
I'm starting book three tomorrow. Send coffee.
















