What happens when three women who've spent centuries hiding the most essential parts of themselves finally just... stop? That question hit me different while I was up at 2 AM redesigning a client's brand identity for the fourth time because they kept saying "it doesn't feel like us." Frida was sprawled across my keyboard, Diego was judging me from the bookshelf, and the Beauchamp women were whispering in my ears about suppression and secrets and the price of pretending to be ordinary.
Here's the thing - I wanted to love this book way more than I actually did.
Three Witches, One Identity Crisis, and a Love Triangle That Made Me Want to Shake Someone
The setup is genuinely good. Joanna, the mother who can literally raise the dead but has to smile through PTA meetings. Ingrid, the librarian daughter who sees the future but shelves books like it's her whole personality. And Freya - wild, messy, about-to-marry-a-rich-mysterious-man Freya who's mixing potions at the bar she tends like cocktails. The metaphor of powerful women forced to dim themselves? That's the kind of thing that makes me think about my abuela, who crossed a border and then spent decades making herself smaller so other people would feel comfortable. Abuela would have loved the premise of this one. She would've been yelling at Freya to stop messing around with two brothers, though. Two brothers! The engaged-to-Bran-but-drawn-to-Killian situation has telenovela DNA all over it, and I mean that as both a compliment and a warning.
But here's where my heart sank a little. De la Cruz comes from YA - the Blue Bloods series - and you can feel it. The emotional beats land at surface level when they should be drilling deep. Freya's torn between two men, and instead of feeling that gut-wrenching impossibility, it reads like... a choice between two flavors at the ice cream shop. The mythology mixes Norse gods with witchcraft with a little bit of everything else, and it's ambitious, but it never quite gels into something that feels lived-in. The world-building is more decorative than structural, like a beautiful font on a weak layout. (Designer brain, sorry.)
I ugly-cried zero times. ZERO. For me, that's practically a negative review by itself.
Katie Schorr Brought Patience When I Needed Fire
Schorr's narration is calm. Measured. She reads like she's placing each sentence down carefully on a table, making sure nothing spills. And for the quieter domestic moments - Joanna in her garden, Ingrid organizing her library stacks - that pace works. There's a stillness to it that makes the contrast between mundane life and hidden magic feel real.
But when Freya's sneaking around with Killian? When the dark forces start circling and a girl goes missing over Fourth of July weekend? I needed heat. I needed Schorr to shift gears, to let her voice crack or race or drop to something dangerous. She doesn't. The three Beauchamp women sound similar enough that I'd sometimes lose track of whose perspective I was in, especially during longer stretches. Joanna gets the most distinct treatment - there's a weariness to how Schorr reads her that hints at centuries of exhaustion - but Freya and Ingrid blur together more than they should for sisters who are supposed to be polar opposites.
At 1.0x, which is my standard, the pacing felt sluggish in the middle hours. This might genuinely be a 1.25x book, which I almost never say. The eight-hour runtime should've felt breezy for a summer supernatural romp, but some stretches dragged like a Monday morning.
Cozy Surface, Shallow Roots
Look, this book felt like a cute sundress you buy on impulse - it's pretty, it's fun for one afternoon, but the seams aren't quite right and you know it won't last. The romantic tension between Freya and the Gardiner brothers has moments of genuine spark, and the slow reveal of why the Beauchamps were banned from magic kept me curious enough to keep listening through my late-night design sessions. But the emotional payoffs are thin. The mystery elements feel underbaked. And the "adult" label is doing some heavy lifting for what still reads like YA with slightly more sexual tension. That YA-dressed-as-adult energy reminded me of reading Pretties, which at least commits fully to its teenage intensity.
If you loved Blue Bloods as a teen and want that same cotton-candy mythology energy with a witchy grown-up coat of paint, you'll probably have a good time. If you're coming in wanting something with the emotional weight of, say, Practical Magic - where the sisterhood actually makes you ache - you'll be left wanting.
Who This Spell Is Actually For
Beach listeners. Hammock readers. People who want witchy vibes without heavy emotional lifting. If you're looking for a palate cleanser between big intense listens, this fits. But if you're like me and you need a book to reach into your chest and rearrange things? Keep scrolling.
My heart stayed intact the whole time. And honestly? That's the saddest thing I can say about a book with three immortal women finally reclaiming their power.
















