Look, I came to The Witcher books backwards. Games first, then the Netflix show, then finally—finally—the source material. And honestly? I'm kicking myself for waiting this long.
Time of Contempt is the second novel in the series proper (after Blood of Elves), and it's where Sapkowski really starts swinging. The political machinations that were simmering in the first book? They boil over here. Spectacularly. And messily. The kind of messy that makes you pause the audiobook and just... sit there for a minute.
Peter Kenny Owns These Characters
I've said it before on the podcast: a fantasy audiobook lives or dies by its narrator. You're asking someone to juggle dozens of characters, multiple accents, invented terminology, and somehow make it all feel cohesive. Peter Kenny doesn't just manage this—he makes it look effortless.
His Geralt has that perfect gravelly weariness. Not overdone, not trying to sound like Henry Cavill (thank god), just... tired. The tired of a man who's seen too much and keeps getting pulled back into things he'd rather avoid. But it's his Dandelion that genuinely surprised me. There's a lightness there, a theatrical quality that makes the bard feel like a fully realized person rather than comic relief.
And Yennefer. Okay, so Yennefer's voice work is fascinating because Kenny doesn't make her cold—he makes her controlled. There's warmth underneath, but you have to earn it. The scenes between her and Ciri? I was listening at 2 AM (Shirley was unimpressed, as usual) and found myself actually holding my breath during some of their training sequences.
When the Continent Catches Fire
Here's the thing about Sapkowski's writing—it's dense. Like, really dense. The political intrigue between the Northern Kingdoms and Nilfgaard, the machinations within the Wizard's Guild, the various factions all playing their own games... it's a lot. I won't pretend I caught every name on the first listen.
But that's also kind of the point? This isn't hand-holding fantasy. Sapkowski trusts you to keep up, and Kenny's pacing helps enormously. He knows when to slow down for the important revelations and when to let the dialogue crackle with urgency.
The Thanedd coup—I'm not spoiling anything major here, it's been discussed to death—is genuinely one of the most chaotic, disorienting sequences I've experienced in fantasy audiobook form. And I mean that as a compliment. You're supposed to feel like everything's falling apart, because it is. Kenny navigates that chaos without losing the thread, which is honestly impressive given how many characters are doing things simultaneously.
The Gut-Punch Moments
Sapkowski has this sardonic edge to his writing that I absolutely love. It's dark fantasy that doesn't take itself too seriously, except when it does—and then it hits you like a truck. There's a scene near the end involving Ciri that... look. I was on a walk. In broad daylight. And I had to stop and compose myself.
The horror elements here aren't supernatural (well, not entirely). They're human. The contempt in the title isn't metaphorical. It's about what people do to each other when power is on the line. My podcast listeners are going to love this—it's the kind of horror that creeps up on you because you're too busy following the plot to notice how dark things have gotten.
I will say: there's one chapter that goes a bit over the top. You'll know it when you hear it. Some listeners found it less funny than intended, and I can see that. It didn't ruin anything for me, but it's a tonal wobble in an otherwise tight experience.
Who's This For (And Who Should Skip)
If you're already invested in Geralt, Ciri, and Yennefer's story, Time of Contempt is where everything gets complicated in the best possible way. But if you're jumping into the Witcher books for the first time? Don't start here. Go back to The Last Wish and Sword of Destiny for the short stories, then Blood of Elves. Kenny's narration of The Last Wish is where you'll first hear him nail these characters—it's worth experiencing his range from the beginning. Skip this one if you need fantasy that holds your hand through the politics; Sapkowski won't slow down for you.
Already Planning the Relisten
There's too much going on to catch everything the first time, and honestly, I want to experience Kenny's performance again now that I know where it's all heading. He brings that same layered approach to Lady of the Lake, where knowing the destination makes his character choices even more devastating. The Booktrack edition apparently has background music, which I didn't try—I'm a purist about that stuff, and the clean audio version is excellent.
Twelve hours well spent. Shirley Jackson walked so Sapkowski could run—different genres, same understanding that real horror lives in what humans choose to do.

















