I came to this one backwards. Started with the games, fell into the Netflix hole, then finally picked up the books like a proper convert. Season of Storms sits in this weird chronological space that Sapkowski seems to love throwing at readers. It's technically a prequel but published last, set between short stories most people read first. Classic Sapkowski chaos.
And honestly? I kind of love that about him.
The Witcher Without His Swords
The premise here is almost absurdly simple for a fantasy novel: Geralt loses his swords. That's it. That's the inciting incident. But Sapkowski takes this seemingly mundane problem and spins it into something that touches on sorcerer politics, monster contracts gone sideways, and the kind of morally gray situations that make the Witcher series what it is.
This isn't the epic, world-shaking narrative of the main saga. It's smaller. More personal. Geralt wandering through a storm season (literally and metaphorically), dealing with petty nobles and scheming mages while trying to get his damn weapons back. Some readers find this frustrating—where's the destiny? Where's Ciri? But I found it refreshing. Sometimes you just want to watch a monster hunter do monster hunter things without the weight of prophecy hanging over everything.
The narrative does jump around quite a bit. Sapkowski's never been one for linear storytelling, and here it can feel scattered. There were moments where I genuinely lost track of which subplot we were following. Not a dealbreaker, but if you're listening while doing dishes or commuting, you might need to rewind a few times.
Peter Kenny Is the Witcher's Voice
Here's where I get emphatic. Peter Kenny doesn't just narrate these books—he inhabits them. His Geralt has this perfect world-weary rasp, cynical but not cruel, tired but never quite broken. He brings that same exhausted-but-enduring quality to Lady of the Lake, where Geralt's weariness hits even harder. After nearly twelve hours with him, I genuinely cannot imagine these stories in anyone else's voice.
The man does things with accents that shouldn't work but absolutely do. Each character sounds distinct, grounded in their region and station. When Dandelion shows up (and of course he does), Kenny shifts into this perfectly insufferable bard energy that made me laugh out loud on my evening walk. My neighbors probably think I'm unhinged.
Now. The female voices. Yeah, they can get a little rough. It's not terrible, but there's a noticeable drop in polish when he's voicing certain women characters. Does it pull me out of the story? Occasionally. Is it enough to dock serious points? Not for me, but I know listeners who'd disagree.
His pacing, though—that's where Kenny really shines. He knows when to let a scene breathe and when to push through action sequences. The monster fights hit different when he's controlling the rhythm. There's this encounter with a lamia that genuinely had me walking faster, heart rate up, completely absorbed. That's the mark of a narrator who understands audiobooks are a performance medium.
The Sapkowski Flavor
If you've read the other Witcher books, you know what you're getting: that slightly cynical humor, the philosophical tangents that somehow work, the way violence is treated as ugly and necessary rather than glorified. Sapkowski doesn't write power fantasies. He writes about a man doing a hard job in a world that doesn't appreciate him for it.
The translation by David French captures this well—there's a rhythm to the prose that feels intentional, almost lyrical in places. Some of the dialogue exchanges are genuinely sharp. Geralt's dry responses to increasingly absurd situations never get old.
Fair warning on content: violence (expected), language (also expected), and some sexual content handled in that very European way where it just... happens. Nothing gratuitous, but definitely present.
Who Should Queue This Up (And Who Shouldn't)
If you're already invested in the Witcher world, this is a no-brainer. It's not the strongest entry in the series—that honor still goes to Blood of Elves for me—but it's a solid, enjoyable return to a character I genuinely love spending time with. Skip this if you haven't read the earlier books; dropping in cold would be disorienting, and you'd miss half the pleasure of seeing familiar faces.
New to Sapkowski? Start with The Last Wish instead. It gives you the foundation this book expects you to already have—and Kenny's narration there is just as stellar.
And for the love of all that's holy, avoid the Booktrack edition. I've heard the music mixing is distracting at best, actively annoying at worst. Stick with the clean version and let Kenny's performance carry you through.
Comfort Food for the Continent
My podcast listeners are going to appreciate this one—it's comfort listening for fantasy fans. Not revolutionary, not essential, but deeply satisfying in that way only returning to a beloved world can be. Sometimes that's exactly what you need.

















