What happens when the girl who saved Oz comes back and turns into the villain?
That's the premise of Dorothy Must Die, and honestly, it's the kind of hook that grabbed me immediately. I'm a sucker for fairy tale retellings - give me a twisted version of something I already know and I'm in. That same dark reimagining energy pulled me into Battlefield Earth, though that one's sci-fi instead of fantasy. But here's the thing: at 14 hours, this is a BIG commitment for a mom whose longest uninterrupted listening window is a toddler nap that may or may not happen. So was it worth it?
Mostly. Yeah. Mostly.
When Kansas Girls Go to War
Amy Gumm is our new girl from Kansas, and she's nothing like Dorothy. She's got a deadbeat mom, pink hair, and exactly zero desire to be anyone's hero. When a tornado drops her into Oz, she finds the place completely wrecked - Dorothy came back, got addicted to magic, and basically turned into a glitter-covered dictator. The Tin Woodman is ripping out people's hearts. The Scarecrow is doing creepy brain experiments. The Lion feeds on fear. And Dorothy? She's ruling it all in her sparkly shoes with a terrifying perma-smile.
The concept is genuinely clever. "The Good is the Wicked" - that line stuck with me through three school pickups and a pediatrician waiting room. The Revolutionary Order of the Wicked recruits Amy to take down Dorothy's crew piece by piece: steal the Tin Woodman's heart, the Scarecrow's brain, the Lion's courage. It's dark, it's violent (heads up - this is NOT your seven-year-old's Oz), and the world-building in the first half is really fun to sink into.
But. The middle. Oh, the middle. There's a long training section where Amy learns magic and combat and it just... sits there. I found myself zoning out during car time, which is supposed to be my sacred focused-listening hour. I'd come back from a pause and realize I hadn't missed much. That's never a great sign. The pacing picks up significantly toward the end though - the last few hours are genuinely exciting and I was actually annoyed when Sophie woke up from her nap right when things got intense.
Devon Sorvari's Dorothy Will Haunt Your Minivan
Here's where I'm torn. Devon Sorvari does some things really well. Her Dorothy voice? Chilling. She nails this sweet-but-unhinged quality that made my skin crawl in the best way - like if a pageant queen had absolute power and zero conscience. And she captures Amy's frustration and determination in a way that feels authentic to a pissed-off teenager who didn't ask for any of this.
But sometimes the narration felt weirdly clipped and almost angry in places where it didn't need to be. There were a few pauses that felt technical rather than dramatic - like the audio was stitched together a little roughly. It pulled me out of the story a couple of times. Not a dealbreaker, but noticeable. If you're comparing this to, say, the narration on something like The Lunar Chronicles audiobooks where the performance is consistently polished, this one's a step below.
Also - there's a romance subplot. I need to mention it because it annoyed me more than it should have. It felt shoehorned in and I kept wanting to get back to the actual rebellion. When you have limited listening time, a romance that doesn't earn its place feels like it's stealing minutes from you.
Who's Going to Love This (And Who Should Skip)
If you've got a tween or young teen who loves dark fairy tales, this is a solid pick. My Emma is too young for it (definitely too violent for 7), but I could see handing this to a 12-or-13-year-old who's ready for something edgier than middle grade. For adult listeners, it reads young - it IS YA - but the Oz reimagining is creative enough to keep you interested if you go in with the right expectations.
Skip it if you need tight pacing throughout. That saggy middle is real. And if you're easily bugged by narration quirks, maybe try a sample first.
Car Time Verdict: Worth It With an Asterisk
I finished this over about ten days, which is longer than my usual. It survived the 47-pause test - the plot is straightforward enough that I never felt lost coming back to it, even after a full day away. The ending left me wanting to know what happens next, which is both satisfying and annoying because that's three more books and when exactly am I supposed to find that time?
Not groundbreaking, but sometimes you don't need groundbreaking. Sometimes you need a story where the good witch is actually wicked and a scrappy girl from a trailer park gets to burn it all down. I listened to most of this during nap time and late-night car sits, and it kept me company just fine. Just be prepared to push through that middle section - the payoff at the end is worth the slog.
















