Does finishing a fantasy trilogy from the 80s count as a personality trait at this point? Because I've been listening to Feist's Riftwar Saga for what feels like half my commutes this year, and finally reaching the end of Darkness at Sethanon hit different.
Here's the thing—this is basically the MCU Endgame of 80s fantasy. Everything Feist built across Magician and Silverthorn comes crashing together in this 19-hour epic, and I mean crashing. We're talking interdimensional battles, time travel to the literal dawn of creation, and Pug finally getting to do the ridiculously overpowered magician stuff we've been waiting for. The scope is wild. "Fate of a thousand worlds" isn't marketing hyperbole here—Feist actually goes there.
The Pronunciation Problem (And Why I Pushed Through Anyway)
Okay, I need to address the elephant in the room. Nicholas Guy Smith mispronounces names. Multiple names. Names you've been hearing correctly in your head for potentially decades if you read these books as a kid. I caught myself mentally correcting "Murmandamus" at least three times per commute, and honestly? It's annoying. No sugarcoating it.
But—and this is a big but—Smith does something that matters more to me: he treats every character like they deserve to be there. The villains get the same careful attention as Pug and Arutha. The side characters don't become afterthoughts. In a book juggling this many plot threads across multiple dimensions, that consistency actually saved the experience for me. I've listened to narrators who nail every pronunciation but phone in the secondary cast, and that's way worse for a 19-hour listen.
His pacing is steady. Maybe too steady for some—I saw reviews calling it monotone, and I get it. This isn't Ray Porter bringing theatrical energy to every scene. It's more like a reliable DM running a campaign: clear, even, occasionally great at the big moments but not trying to steal the show. At 1.5x, it worked perfectly for my morning zombie state.
Where Feist Actually Delivers
The time travel sequence to the dawn of creation? That's the good stuff. Pug wrestling with cosmic forces, the mythology of the world finally clicking into place—I actually missed my stop because I was so locked in. (Yes, I had to backtrack from Sunnyvale. Yes, I was late to standup. Worth it.)
Feist's world-building has always been his strength, and this book pays off years of setup. If you've been following the Riftwar Saga, there are moments here that hit hard—character arcs completing, mysteries resolving, the whole Midkemia vs. Kelewan conflict finally making sense in a bigger cosmic context. It's satisfying in a way that modern fantasy series often aren't, because Feist actually wrote an ending.
The battle sequences are dense. Like, really dense. There were stretches where I zoned out during the tactical stuff—I'm not gonna pretend I tracked every troop movement at 6 AM. Story of a New Name does that same thing—dense political maneuvering that sometimes loses me, but the character work is so strong it doesn't matter. Arutha's arc in particular lands well.
The ROI Calculation
19 hours is a commitment. That's basically two weeks of commutes for me. Is it worth it if you haven't read the previous books? Absolutely not—this is Book 3 of a trilogy, and you'll be completely lost. But if you've already invested in Magician and Silverthorn? Yeah, finish it. The payoff is there.
Perfect for: long commutes, gym sessions where you don't need to track complex info constantly. Skip if: you haven't read the first two books, you're a pronunciation purist who's been reading these since the 80s, or you need something for deep focus work—there's too much happening to half-listen.
The mispronunciation thing is real, and if you're a purist, it might drive you crazy. I'm not gonna lie about that. But Smith's consistency and the clean production quality make this a solid listen overall. Just... maybe don't expect to hear "Tsurani" the way you've always said it in your head.
Closing the Loop After Fifteen Years
I finished this in about 12 commutes at 1.5x. Would I relisten? Probably not—I got what I needed from it. But I'm glad I finally closed out this trilogy after having the paperbacks collect dust on my shelf for fifteen years. Sometimes you just gotta finish what 14-year-old you started, you know?
















