Okay, so here's my complaint: why does Mary Balogh insist on making me feel things before I've even had my morning coffee? I started this audiobook at 6 AM while working on a logo for a wellness brand, and by 7:30 I was crying into my oatmeal because Hugo—this giant, grumpy war hero—just wanted someone to see him as more than his title or his money. Ugh. My heart.
Let me back up. Gwendoline is a widow who's decided she's done with love. Hugo is a merchant's son who earned his lordship through battlefield heroics and now has to find a wife because... society. They meet when she literally falls and he scoops her up like some Regency-era firefighter. And look, that sounds like every historical romance ever, but Balogh does something different here. She makes you wait. She makes you earn it.
The Slow Burn That Wrecked Me
This is not a book where they hate each other and then suddenly they're kissing against a wall. (I love those books too, don't get me wrong.) This is a book where two people who've been hurt—really hurt—slowly, carefully decide to trust each other. Hugo doesn't know how to court a woman. He's blunt and awkward and keeps saying the wrong thing, and honestly? It's adorable. Gwen has to teach him that vulnerability isn't weakness, and watching him learn... I ugly-cried at least three times.
The pacing is slow. I'm not gonna lie to you. There are long stretches of internal monologue where Gwen is processing her grief or Hugo is wrestling with his insecurities. If you need action every chapter, this might test your patience. But if you're like me—if you listen to romance to feel something real—this book delivers. The chemistry is chef's kiss. Not because it's explosive, but because it's earned.
Rebecca De Leeuw Knows When to Hold Back
Here's the thing about narrating a slow-burn Regency romance: you can't rush it. And Rebecca De Leeuw doesn't. Her voice is warm and clear, and she handles the emotional beats with this quiet intensity that just works. When Hugo finally opens up about his past, she doesn't oversell it. She lets the words do the heavy lifting, and it hit me right in the chest.
Some listeners found her pacing too languid. I get it—at 12 and a half hours, this is not a quick listen. But honestly? The slower delivery matches the book's vibe perfectly. This is a rainy Sunday book. Meant to be savored, not speedrun. If you're impatient, maybe bump it up to 1.25x, but I listened at my usual 1.0 and it felt right.
Her character voices are subtle—she's not doing wildly different accents for everyone—but you can always tell who's speaking. Hugo sounds heavier, more deliberate. Gwen has this lightness that makes her infectious laugh feel real even when you're just hearing it described. I was completely pulled in, and that's saying something because I was also trying to finalize a color palette while listening.
Abuela Would Have Loved This One
I kept thinking about my grandmother while listening to this. She loved stories about people finding love after loss—about second chances that feel miraculous but also hard-won. Gwen's journey from grief to hope reminded me of conversations we used to have about her own life, about how love doesn't replace what you've lost but adds something new.
That careful belief in second chances is why I also keep thinking about Someone to Trust.Mary Balogh writes like someone who understands that romance isn't just about the happy ending. It's about the mess that comes before it. The doubt. The fear. The way two people have to choose each other over and over again. Her style is old-world and detailed—some might say wordy—but it works for this kind of story. Not Jane Austen exactly, but in that neighborhood.
Who This Is (and Isn't) For
If you need fast pacing and constant action, skip this one. But if you're a sucker for wounded heroes learning to be vulnerable, patient heroines who've survived grief, and love stories that feel earned rather than instant—this is your book. Balogh veterans will recognize her at her best here.
That quietly devastating, earned-romance thing is also why Only Enchanting stays on my Mary Balogh shelf.Going on My Comfort Re-Listen List
Yes. Absolutely yes. Maybe not right away—I need to emotionally recover first—but this is the kind of audiobook you put on when you need to remember that love is possible, even when you've convinced yourself it isn't. De Leeuw's lovely voice and emotional tone made even the slower beginning feel like being held.
Frida sat on my keyboard for most of the last hour, which is her way of saying she approved. Diego hid under the bed, but he's a thriller cat. He doesn't get romance.











