Confession time. I cheated on the horror genre.
Shirley (my cat) sat on my chest while I listened to this, staring into my soul with her yellow eyes as if to ask, "Where are the ghosts, Jordan? Where is the existential dread? We usually listen to people screaming in the woods at this hour."
And look—she has a point. Usually, if a book doesn't make me check the locks twice, I'm not interested. But I needed a break from demons, and Richard Osman's Thursday Murder Club gang is the only squad I'd leave the darkness for. Plus, Lesley Manville is narrating. If you saw Phantom Thread, you know she can be terrifying with just a single glance. Here, she does it with just her voice. So, I poured a glass of wine, ignored the pile of unread horror ARCs on my nightstand, and hit play.
When Acting Trumps Reading
Let's be real for a second. Most celebrity narrators are... fine. They show up, read the words clearly, collect the check.
Manville? She inhabits these people.
Elizabeth (the ex-spy) sounds clipped, dangerous, and tired of everyone's incompetence. Joyce sounds like your grandmother who might accidentally poison you with kindness—or actual poison, depending on the day. Manville understands that comedy is entirely about rhythm. Miss the beat by a millisecond, the joke dies. She doesn't miss. Not once.
(There were a few moments where the pitch got a little high for my headphones—sorry, sensory issues are a pain—but I forgave her immediately because the character work is just that solid.)
The Slow Burn vs. The Body Count
I'll be honest—the first hour? It dragged a little.
I was literally reorganizing the Dewey Decimal 800s at the library, thinking, "Okay, let's get to the murder, please. I have shelf-reading to do."
It takes a minute to set up the stolen diamonds, the mobsters, and the ex-husband. But once the bodies start piling up (and they do—this isn't that cozy), the pacing snaps into place.
It's not "scary," obviously. I didn't have to turn the lights on. But there's a different kind of dread here—the dread of running out of time. Of being old and underestimated. Affair: A Jack Reacher Novel plays with that same underestimation angle, though Reacher's version involves a lot more broken bones. This feels grounded in a way a lot of thrillers forget to be.
Also, the dialogue? Sharp as a tack. It's funny in a way that makes you look like a crazy person laughing alone on the bus. (Don't ask me how I know. It was awkward.)
Why a Horror Junkie Loved It
If you've been binging true crime or heavy psychological thrillers where everyone is miserable, your brain is probably mush. This is the antidote. It's smart, it's British, and it respects the reader's intelligence. It doesn't hold your hand.
Shirley eventually fell asleep, so I guess it wasn't chaotic enough for her tastes. But for me? A perfect 12 hours of escapism. (Oh, and the interview between Osman and Manville at the end? Surprisingly charming. Usually I skip those, but I stayed for this one.)
Who's This For (And Who Should Skip)
If you liked the first book, this is arguably better—the stakes feel higher. If you haven't started the series, what are you doing? But if you need constant action or can't handle a slow first hour of setup, maybe grab something with more immediate body counts. Manville is a queen. Osman is a genius. Go listen.












