I'm just gonna say it: I ugly-cried at a fake dating book. A comedy. Alexis Hall, what have you done to me?
I started this one on a random Tuesday while working on a logo for a local bakery. Frida was judging me from her perch on my desk, Diego was somewhere causing chaos, and I figured—light rom-com, perfect background listening. Reader (listener?), I was not prepared. By hour ten, I had paused my work entirely and was just... sitting there. Feeling things. The bakery logo could wait.
The Voice That Made Me Fall
Joe Jameson. That's it. That's the tweet.
Okay, fine, I'll elaborate. His Luc is this perfect blend of self-deprecating chaos and genuine vulnerability that just—ugh. It hits different. The way he delivers Luc's internal monologue? It's like listening to your messiest friend process their feelings in real time, except somehow it's charming instead of exhausting. And Oliver! Jameson gives him this slightly stiff, overly-proper cadence that melts so gradually over thirteen hours that you don't even notice it's happening until suddenly Oliver's making a joke and you're like, wait, when did he become warm?
The accent work is genuinely impressive. We've got British, Welsh, French—a whole buffet of voices that somehow never feel like a party trick. Some listeners mentioned the female voices felt a bit odd, and yeah, okay, a couple of them veered into slightly cartoonish territory. But honestly? The supporting cast in this book ARE a bit cartoonish (affectionately), so it kind of works.
His comic timing though. Chef's kiss. I laughed out loud on my balcony at least four separate times and definitely alarmed my neighbors.
When Fake Dating Stops Being Fake
Here's the thing about this book—it knows exactly what it is. Fake dating to real feelings isn't groundbreaking. The third-act conflict is... conventional, let's say. But Alexis Hall writes with this sharp, witty voice that makes everything feel fresh. Luc is a disaster bisexual with daddy issues and a talent for self-sabotage, and Oliver is a buttoned-up barrister who's never been messy a day in his life. On paper, it's tropey as hell.
In practice? The chemistry is electric.
The slow burn here is exquisite. And I mean slow—we're talking thirteen hours of tension, of almost-moments, of Luc convincing himself this can't possibly be real while Oliver just... quietly falls. The vulnerability in the second half wrecked me. There's this scene—I won't spoil it—but Jameson's delivery made me pause my work and just sit with it. My heart. MY HEART. Song of Achilles did the same thing to me—that same gut-punch of emotional devastation wrapped in beautiful prose.
Abuela would have loved this one. She'd have been scandalized by some of the spicier bits (and there are some—fair warning), but she lived for a good enemies-to-lovers arc. Fake dating is basically the same energy.
Curl Up and Feel Something
This is a rainy Sunday book. Or a long road trip book. Or a "I need to feel something other than deadline stress" book. The vibes are immaculate—funny and sharp but with this undercurrent of genuine emotion that sneaks up on you.
Is it perfect? No. Some of the supporting characters lean a little caricature-ish, and if you're not into contemporary romance tropes, this probably won't convert you. But if you're like me—if you want a book that makes you laugh and then suddenly makes you cry in your home office while your cats stare at you—this is it. Skip it if British humor leaves you cold or if you need your romances plot-heavy rather than character-driven.
Joe Jameson won an AudioFile Best Audiobook award for this, and honestly? Deserved. He takes an already excellent book and elevates it into something special. The kind of performance where you forget you're listening to someone read words and just... live in it.
I listened at 1.0x because I'm not a monster, and also because Jameson's comedic timing deserves to breathe. Speeding this up would be a crime.
I immediately started the sequel. No regrets. Diego knocked my headphones off the desk twice during the first chapter and I didn't even care.














