Walking the Lakefront with Anne
There's something almost meditative about returning to Avonlea. I started this one on a Sunday morning walk along Lake Michigan with Denise, and by the time we'd circled back to our starting point, I'd already decided to stretch the walk another mile just to keep listening. That's the thing about Montgomery's writing - it doesn't demand anything from you. It just... invites you in. And after twenty years of forcing teenagers to analyze symbolism in The Great Gatsby, sometimes you need a book that feels like a warm cup of tea instead of an exam.
Anne Shirley is sixteen now, teaching at the Avonlea school, and honestly? She's still the same delightfully dramatic, imagination-drunk girl we met in Green Gables. If you haven't read Anne of Green Gables yet, start thereβthis sequel assumes you already know why Anne capitalizes Kindred Spirits in her head. The plot isn't exactly high-stakes - we're talking about village improvement societies, twin orphans, and whether various neighbors will ever stop being insufferable. But Montgomery understood something that a lot of modern writers forget: character is plot. Watching Anne navigate small-town politics while trying to maintain her idealism? That's the story. And it's enough.
Karen Savage Gets It
Look, I've listened to a lot of classic lit audiobooks where the narrator treats the material like it's homework. You know the type - technically proficient, utterly lifeless. Karen Savage is the opposite. Her Anne sounds genuinely young, which matters more than you'd think. There's a breathless quality to her delivery during Anne's more dramatic proclamations that just works. When Anne is being theatrical about some minor setback, Savage leans into it without mocking her. She understands that Anne takes everything seriously, and the narrator should too.
Savage brings that same authenticity to Railway Children, where she nails the voices of kids who actually sound like kids instead of tiny adults.
The character voices are solid across the board. Marilla's dry practicality comes through clearly, and the various Avonlea busybodies each get their own flavor of small-minded concern. (My students would absolutely hate Mrs. Lynde. I find her weirdly comforting - every school has a Mrs. Lynde in the faculty lounge, and at least Montgomery's version is honest about her nosiness.)
The pacing deserves mention here too. Savage reads at what I'd call a "savoring" pace - not slow, but deliberate. Montgomery's sentences have a rhythm to them, almost Victorian in their construction, and Savage honors that without making it feel stuffy. This is why I listen at 1.0x, people. The author chose those words.
Fair Warning: The Chapter Thing
Okay, so there's one quirk. At the end of each chapter, there's an announcement - "End of Chapter Seven" or whatever - and it's a little jarring. Not a dealbreaker by any means, but if you're the type who gets pulled out of immersion easily, you'll notice it. I was grading papers during some of the middle chapters (11 PM, red pen in hand, the usual glamour of a teacher's life) and the announcements actually helped me track where I was. So maybe it's a feature, not a bug? Your mileage may vary.
The audio quality is generally clean. There were a couple moments where I noticed something slightly off - nothing I could pinpoint exactly, maybe just older recording equipment - but honestly, I've listened to professionally produced audiobooks with worse sound. It's not distracting unless you're actively looking for problems.
Who Should Listen (And Who Should Skip)
This is for anyone who loved Anne of Green Gables and wants more of that world. But it's also for people who need something gentle in their ears - commuters dealing with Chicago traffic, parents folding laundry at midnight, teachers pretending to pay attention during budget presentations. (Principal Martinez, I'm kidding. Mostly.)
Skip this if you need constant plot momentum - Montgomery is interested in the texture of daily life, not narrative urgency. She's writing about how communities work, how people change (or don't), how a young woman figures out who she wants to be. It's quiet stuff. Beautiful, but quiet. And if you're coming to Montgomery for the first time, start with Green Gables - this sequel assumes you already know these people.
My students would hate this. I love it.
The Verdict
Karen Savage's narration elevates an already lovely book into something genuinely comforting. She brings warmth without sentimentality, and her Anne feels authentic in a way that lesser narrators miss entirely. The chapter announcements are mildly annoying, sure, but they're a small price for what is otherwise a really satisfying listening experience.
This reminds me of what Hemingway said about prose - that the dignity of movement of an iceberg is due to only one-eighth of it being above water. Montgomery's writing looks simple on the surface, but there's so much underneath about belonging, about growing up, about finding your place in a world that doesn't always understand you. Savage's narration lets all of that breathe.
Worth pausing the faculty meeting for. Definitely worth another lap around the lake.

















