After a twelve-hour shift where I literally had to explain to a patient why they shouldn't eat the hospital jello before their surgery, I don't want high art. I don't want a complex geopolitical thriller. I want to turn my brain off. I want to laugh.
So when I saw Wallbanger, I thought—perfect.
I listened to this on the drive home—the dreaded 45-minute commute where I try to transition from "Trauma Nurse Maria" to "Mom who makes pancakes." And honestly? I almost woke the neighbors when I pulled into the driveway because I was laughing so hard at the cat.
The Wallbanger Situation
Here's the setup: Caroline moves into a gorgeous apartment (San Francisco real estate porn, honestly), but the walls are paper-thin. And her neighbor, Simon? He's... active. Very active. We're talking bed-banging against the wall, different women every night, loud noises active.
As a nurse, I'm used to hearing things I shouldn't. I've heard confessions, family fights, and yes, activities behind curtains that aren't nearly as soundproof as people think. So Caroline's frustration? I felt that in my soul.
The book starts with a lot of banging. And moaning.
(Pro tip: Roll your windows up if you're listening to the first chapter at a stoplight. The guy in the Prius next to me gave me a very concerned look. I just pointed at my scrubs and shrugged. Let him wonder.)
But underneath the noise complaints and the sexual frustration, this is actually a really sweet, funny story. It's a slow burn—which, considering the title, is kind of ironic. It's mostly about Caroline losing her mind, dealing with her boss, and trying to seduce her neighbor's cat, Clive.
(Clive is the real MVP of this book. If cats could talk, he'd sound like the Chief of Surgery—judgmental and easily bribed with food.)
The Voice (And The Speed Button)
Okay, let's talk about Heather Smith.
I'm gonna be real with you—the reviews are all over the place on this one. Some people said she sounds like a preschool teacher reading a bedtime story. And... I kind of get it? She has this very clear, precise, slightly breathy voice.
At 1.0x speed, it felt a little slow. Like, "we get it, move it along" slow.
But here's the trick—and this is coming from someone who listens to doctors dictate notes at 2x speed—bump this baby up to 1.25x or even 1.5x. Suddenly, that "nanny voice" turns into snappy, witty banter. The pacing issues vanish.
Once I adjusted the speed, Smith actually nailed the comedic timing. She does a great job with Caroline's internal monologue, which is about 80% of the book. She captures that specific brand of female neurosis where you overanalyze a text message for three hours. We've all been there.
Who's This For (And Who Should Skip)
If you want something light after a brutal week, something that'll make you laugh in your car like a weirdo—this is your book. Skip it if you need substance or if overly cutesy banter makes you cringe. The "trying too hard to be Gilmore Girls" moments might push you over the edge.
Clocking Out With a Grin
Is it Shakespeare? No. Is it cheesy? Oh, absolutely. There are moments where the banter tries a little too hard to be "Gilmore Girls" witty and lands somewhere near "awkward elevator talk."
But it's fun. It's light. It's the perfect palate cleanser after a heavy shift or a long week. I had that same "brain off, heart on" feeling with After You: A Novel—different flavor of comfort, same kind of relief. It made me laugh out loud in my car, which kept me awake enough to get home safely.
Carlos asked me why I was grinning when I walked in the door at 7 AM. I told him it was the neighbor. He looked worried until I explained it was an audiobook.
(I didn't mention the moaning parts. Some things are better left unexplained.)














