Callahan Garrity Mystery
Callahan Garrity Mystery is a 4-book audiobook series by Mary Kay Andrews. Every entry below includes narrator ratings, listening context, and a clear verdict — start with Every Crooked Nanny.
Books in This Series
Every Crooked Nanny
A fun, character-driven cozy mystery carried by a sharp protagonist and Hillary Huber's perfectly husky narration. Entertaining comfort listening, not emotionally heavy.
Homemade Sin
A tight, well-plotted cozy mystery with a smart protagonist and snappy prose from a former journalist. The audiobook is held back by unconvincing Southern accents and mispronounced Atlanta place names that undercut the setting.
Midnight Clear: A Novel
Seventh in the Callahan Garrity series, this cozy Christmas mystery won't blow your mind but delivers warm family chaos with a body count. Hillary Huber's narration elevates the material perfectly for interrupted, low-stakes listening.
Irish Eyes: A Novel
Cozy mystery with real emotional weight about a cleaning lady detective investigating whether her shot friend was actually dirty. Solid narration with some regional pronunciation quirks that may bother Georgia listeners.
📖 Reading Order
Books are listed in recommended listening order. For the best experience, we suggest starting from Book #1 and progressing through the series sequentially.
Ready to listen free?