Can a love story teach you more about grief than a dozen self-help books?
I've been thinking about this since I finished Kennedy Ryan's Before I Let Go, and honestly, I'm still not sure I have the answer. I had a similar experience with Tale of Two Cities - that feeling of a story lingering long after you've finished it. But I know this: I listened to most of it while grading a stack of junior essays on The Great Gatsby, and the irony of reading about Fitzgerald's doomed romance while listening to one that might actually survive wasn't lost on me.
What Hemingway Would've Cut (And Why Ryan Didn't)
Look, I'll be honest - at nearly fourteen hours, this book is long. Some listeners have said it runs a couple hours too long, and I can see that argument. But here's the thing about Kennedy Ryan: she's not interested in the clean, economical prose Hemingway championed. She's doing something different. She's letting grief breathe.
Yasmen and Josiah Wade are divorced. They have two kids. They run a business together. And they're still - despite everything - drawn to each other like magnets. It's a second-chance romance, sure, but Ryan doesn't let you forget what broke them in the first place. There's stillbirth here. Mental health struggles. The kind of loss that doesn't just hurt - it reshapes you.
My students would probably call this "too much." They're wrong. (Don't tell them I said that.) The length serves a purpose. You can't rush healing. You can't summarize grief in a montage. Ryan forces you to sit with these characters through the messy, nonlinear process of putting yourself back together - and figuring out if you can put your marriage back together too.
The Voices in My Head
Jakobi Diem and Wesleigh Siobhan do the dual narration here, and they're genuinely good together. Diem brings this warmth and vulnerability to Josiah that makes you understand why Yasmen can't quite let go. His delivery during the heavier emotional scenes? Spot on. There's a tenderness there that never tips into melodrama.
Siobhan is passionate and emotionally present throughout. Now, I did notice - and some other listeners have mentioned this - her voice reads younger than I expected for Yasmen. It's not a dealbreaker, but if you're picturing a woman in her thirties who's been through hell and back, the voice occasionally feels like it belongs to someone a bit younger. That said, her chemistry with Diem is undeniable. When they're playing off each other - especially in the more intimate scenes - it works. Really works.
The production is clean. There's some music and effects woven in that enhance rather than distract. No complaints there.
The Slow Burn That Paid Off
This is a book that rewards patience. The stolen kisses, the illicit reconnection, the heat - it's all there. But Ryan earns it. She doesn't let Yasmen and Josiah fall back into each other's arms without making them (and you) reckon with everything that went wrong the first time.
What struck me most was how honest the book is about Black love and identity. Ryan's research shows. It's the kind of intentional, grounded storytelling I appreciated in Rich People Problems, where cultural identity shapes every relationship dynamic. The cultural specificity isn't window dressing - it's integral to who these characters are and how they navigate their world. As someone who teaches literature, I appreciate when an author does the work. Ryan clearly does.
I found myself pausing during faculty meetings more than once. (Principal Martinez, I promise I was paying attention to the budget presentation. I wasn't. I was listening to Josiah try to win his wife back.) There's a scene - I won't spoil it - where the weight of everything they've lost just... lands. I had to stop grading. I had to just sit with it.
Who This Is (And Isn't) For
This isn't a book for everyone. If you're looking for light, breezy romance, keep scrolling. If themes of stillbirth, divorce, and mental health struggles hit too close to home, please take care of yourself and maybe skip this one. There's passive suicidal ideation mentioned, and Ryan doesn't shy away from the darkness.
But if you want a love story that feels real - painfully, beautifully real - this delivers. It's the kind of book that makes you think about what it actually means to love someone for a lifetime. Not the fairy tale version. The version where you have to choose each other again and again, even after you've hurt each other.
Mr. Williams's Final Grade
Denise asked me why I was so quiet on our lakefront walk last week. I told her I was thinking about second chances. She gave me a look. (We've been married twenty-three years. She knows when I've been listening to something heavy.)
Kennedy Ryan wrote something that matters here. Diem and Siobhan gave it voice and breath. At nearly fourteen hours, it's a commitment. But some stories deserve the time.












